Choosing aftermarket wheels for your Tesla Model S can dramatically change its appearance and driving dynamics. The best options balance style, durability, and weight, but tradeoffs often involve cost, compatibility, and ride comfort. The 21-inch Replacement Wheel Set stands out for its balance of quality and affordability, making it the top overall pick. The Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Black) attract attention for their sleek design and premium feel, while the 19″ OEM Reconditioned Wheels offer a budget-friendly option for those prioritizing cost. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of each choice and what to consider when upgrading your Tesla’s wheels.
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top-rated wheels combine lightweight materials with durable construction for improved handling and efficiency.
- Price varies significantly, with reconditioned OEM options offering savings but potentially less longevity.
- Design choices impact not just style but also aerodynamics and noise levels during driving.
- Compatibility and proper sizing are critical to avoid fitment issues and maintain safety standards.
- Premium wheels often provide better heat dissipation and corrosion resistance, justifying higher costs.
| 21-inch Replacement Wheel Set (4 Wheels) for Tesla Model S |  | Best Overall Replacement for Classic Tesla Model S | Size: 21 inches | Number of Wheels: 4 | Compatible Models: Tesla Model S (2012-2017) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Black) |  | Best DIY Upgrade for Scroll Wheel Replacement | Compatibility: Tesla Model S/X | Color: Black | Quantity: Set of 2 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 21 x 9.5 Replacement Wheel for Tesla Model S Front 2022-2024 Charcoal Rim |  | Best for Newer Model S Front Wheel Replacement | Size: 21 x 9.5 inches | Fitment: Tesla Model S 2022-2024 | Color: Charcoal | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Blue) |  | Best Colorful Upgrade for Scroll Wheel Accents | Compatibility: Tesla Model S/X | Color: Blue | Material: Metal | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 21 Inch Charcoal Aluminum Alloy Wheel Rims for Tesla Model S (2012-2017) |  | Best OEM-Style Wheel for Classic Model S | Size: 21 inches | Width: 8.5 inches | Color: Charcoal | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 19″ OEM Wheel for Tesla Model S (2016), Reconditioned, Black |  | Best Replacement for Authentic Fit and Certification | Size: 19 inches | Compatible Model: Tesla Model S | Year: 2016 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| aftermarket wheels for tesla model | Color | Size | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21-inch Replacement Wheel Set | — | 21 inches | — |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll | Black | — | Metal |
| 21 x 9.5 Replacement Wheel for | Charcoal | 21 x 9.5 inches | — |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll | Blue | — | Metal |
| 21 Inch Charcoal Aluminum Allo | Charcoal | 21 inches | Aluminum alloy |
| 19" OEM Wheel for Tesla Model | Black | 19 inches | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
21-inch Replacement Wheel Set (4 Wheels) for Tesla Model S
This 21-inch wheel set stands out for its compatibility with Tesla Model S models from 2012 to 2017, offering both OEM and replica styles that meet industry standards. Compared with the single replacement options, this set provides a more comprehensive upgrade, especially if you’re replacing multiple wheels. The main tradeoff is its limited fitment to earlier Model S years, which means newer models require different sizes. Its certification ensures quality, but without a specific price or customer reviews, buyers should verify fitment and cost for their needs. This set is ideal for owners seeking a reliable, ready-to-install wheel replacement that maintains original aesthetics or slightly customized looks.
Pros:- Compatible with Tesla Model S (2012-2017)
- Available in OEM and replica styles for customization
- Certified to meet industry standards for safety and quality
Cons:- Limited to specific model years, not suitable for newer variants
- No detailed pricing or customer reviews provided, requiring further research
Best for: Tesla Model S owners with 2012-2017 models seeking a full set replacement that balances OEM authenticity and style variety.
Not ideal for: Owners of newer Model S versions from 2022 onward, since the size and compatibility differ significantly.
- Size:21 inches
- Number of Wheels:4
- Compatible Models:Tesla Model S (2012-2017)
Our verdict“This set makes the most sense for owners of older Model S vehicles needing a trusted, comprehensive wheel replacement.”
Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Black)
This set of two scroll wheels offers a straightforward upgrade for Tesla Model S and X owners aiming to replace broken or worn scroll controls. Compared with the larger wheels, these replacements focus solely on the scroll components, making them perfect for quick, cost-effective fixes. Made in the USA with durable metal and anodized in black, they combine style with longevity. However, since these are replacement parts, they won’t upgrade the vehicle’s overall wheel aesthetics or performance, and installation requires basic DIY skills. They are ideal for owners comfortable with minor car repairs who want a reliable, visually appealing fix for damaged scroll wheels.
Pros:- Easy DIY installation in about an hour
- Durable metal construction with lifetime guarantee
- Anodized black finish offers a sleek, customized look
Cons:- Designed solely as replacement parts, not upgrades
- Limited to specific Tesla models, not a universal fit
Best for: Tesla owners looking for an affordable, easy-to-install fix for broken scroll controls on Model S or X.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a full wheel upgrade or aesthetic enhancement beyond the scroll controls, as these are limited to small interior components.
- Compatibility:Tesla Model S/X
- Color:Black
- Quantity:Set of 2
- Material:Metal
- Origin:Made in the USA
Our verdict“This pick makes sense for owners needing a quick, durable fix for broken scroll wheels without replacing entire control units.”
21 x 9.5 Replacement Wheel for Tesla Model S Front 2022-2024 Charcoal Rim
This 21×9.5 front wheel caters specifically to Tesla Model S from 2022 to 2024, featuring a stylish charcoal rim that complements recent design updates. Unlike the 21-inch set designed for earlier models, this wheel offers a perfect fit for the latest vehicles, ensuring aesthetic consistency and functional compatibility. Its high-quality construction guarantees durability, but since it’s a front-only wheel, owners will need to purchase additional wheels for a complete set. Moreover, it doesn’t include accessories like lugs or center caps, which could add to the total cost. This product suits owners who want a direct replacement that preserves their vehicle’s modern look.
Pros:- Exact fit for Tesla Model S (2022-2024)
- Stylish charcoal rim design enhances modern aesthetics
- High-quality construction ensures long-term durability
Cons:- Limited to front wheels only, requiring additional purchases
- No included accessories like lugs or center caps
Best for: Owners of Tesla Model S 2022-2024 needing a high-quality, exact-fit front wheel replacement with a contemporary style.
Not ideal for: Those with older Model S vehicles or seeking a full set upgrade, since this is front-specific and tailored to recent models.
- Size:21 x 9.5 inches
- Fitment:Tesla Model S 2022-2024
- Color:Charcoal
Our verdict“This wheel makes the most sense for owners needing a precise, stylish front replacement for recent Model S models.”
Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Blue)
This set of two scroll wheels in anodized blue offers a vibrant upgrade for Tesla Model S and X owners who want a splash of color in their interior controls. Compared to the black version, the blue wheels provide a more eye-catching, personalized look, making them ideal for owners who want a distinctive interior flair. The durable metal construction ensures long-lasting performance, and installation remains straightforward for DIY enthusiasts. Still, since they are only replacement scroll wheels, they don’t impact overall wheel performance or aesthetics beyond the interior. This choice is best for those who desire a colorful accent rather than a full wheel overhaul.
Pros:- Vivid anodized blue finish adds a custom, energetic look
- Durable metal guarantees long-term use
- Simple DIY installation takes about an hour
Cons:- Limited to specific Tesla models, only for scroll controls
- Only available in blue, limiting color options for matching interior themes
Best for: Tesla owners seeking a fun, colorful interior detail that’s easy to install and long-lasting.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a full wheel upgrade or who prefer a more subdued interior look, as these are limited to scroll controls only.
- Compatibility:Tesla Model S/X
- Color:Blue
- Material:Metal
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for owners wanting a colorful, easy-to-install accent that enhances interior personalization.”
21 Inch Charcoal Aluminum Alloy Wheel Rims for Tesla Model S (2012-2017)
This 21-inch aluminum alloy wheel rim is tailored for Tesla Model S vehicles from 2012 to 2017, matching OEM specifications for a seamless replacement. Compared to aftermarket wheels, this rim offers a high-quality manufacturing process with low defect rates, giving a factory-like appearance. It’s suitable for owners wanting to restore or upgrade their vehicle’s look with minimal fuss. However, since the price is per wheel, buying a full set increases costs significantly, and it doesn’t include center caps, lugs, or sensors, which could add to the total investment. For owners focused on maintaining a factory aesthetic, this rim delivers a reliable, low-risk option.
Pros:- Perfect fit for Tesla Model S (2012-2017)
- OEM compatible for seamless styling
- High-quality manufacturing with low defect rates
Cons:- Price listed per wheel, making full sets costly
- Center caps, lugs, and sensors are not included, increasing total cost
Best for: Owners of older Model S vehicles looking for a high-quality, OEM-compatible replacement wheel that preserves original styling.
Not ideal for: Those wanting a full aesthetic overhaul or a complete wheel set from a single purchase, as the price is per wheel and additional parts are needed.
- Size:21 inches
- Width:8.5 inches
- Color:Charcoal
- Material:Aluminum alloy
- Tire Size:245/35R21
Our verdict“This rim is best for owners seeking a factory-quality replacement for specific older Model S vehicles that prioritize original appearance and fit.”
19″ OEM Wheel for Tesla Model S (2016), Reconditioned, Black
This reconditioned 19-inch OEM wheel stands out for drivers seeking a genuine Tesla part that maintains the factory look and feel. Compared to aftermarket options like the 21-inch replacement wheel set, this wheel offers a precise fit and adheres to multiple certification standards, ensuring quality and durability. However, its limitation to the 2016 Model S and lack of detailed warranty info may restrict its appeal for those seeking broader compatibility or peace of mind. The reconditioning process boosts reliability, making it a solid choice for owners needing an exact OEM replacement without the premium cost of new wheels.
Tradeoffs: While it guarantees OEM authenticity and certification, it’s only suitable for a specific model year and doesn’t offer customization options or extensive warranty details.
Pros:- OEM fit ensures perfect compatibility with 2016 Tesla Model S
- Reconditioned for quality and durability, extending wheel life
- Certified with multiple industry standards including JWL, VIA, ISO9001
Cons:- Limited to the 2016 Model S, reducing versatility for other years
- No specific warranty or pricing info provided
- No customization options—strictly OEM replacement
Best for: Tesla owners of a 2016 Model S seeking a factory-original replacement wheel with proven certification
Not ideal for: Owners of newer Model S versions or those wanting custom aftermarket styling beyond OEM specs
- Size:19 inches
- Compatible Model:Tesla Model S
- Year:2016
- Color:Black
- Condition:Reconditioned
- Certification:JWL, VIA, ISO9001, QS9000, TS16949
Our verdict“This wheel makes the most sense for 2016 Model S owners prioritizing authenticity and certified quality over customization or broader compatibility.”
How We Picked
The products were selected based on a combination of factors including build quality, weight, compatibility with Tesla Model S models from 2012 to 2026, and customer feedback. We prioritized options that offer a clear balance of style, durability, and value, while also considering ease of installation and maintenance needs. Each wheel set was evaluated for its materials, design features, and reputation among Tesla owners. The ranking reflects a mix of performance benefits and practical considerations, helping buyers find wheels suited for different priorities—whether performance, aesthetics, or cost savings.| aftermarket wheels for tesla model | Color | Material |
|---|---|---|
| 21-inch Replacement Wheel Set | — | — |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll | Black | Metal |
| 21 x 9.5 Replacement Wheel for | Charcoal | — |
| Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll | Blue | Metal |
| 21 Inch Charcoal Aluminum Allo | Charcoal | Aluminum alloy |
| 19" OEM Wheel for Tesla Model | Black | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Aftermarket Wheels For Tesla Model S
Selecting the right aftermarket wheels for your Tesla Model S involves more than just choosing a style. Consider factors like size and offset to ensure proper fitment without interference or safety issues. Material quality influences weight, ride comfort, and longevity, so investing in alloys like aluminum often provides better performance. Price is a key consideration, but cheaper reconditioned or OEM replacements may sacrifice durability or aesthetics. Compatibility with your specific model year and driving habits is essential, so double-check specifications before purchasing. Finally, think about how wheels will complement your vehicle’s overall look and whether you need features like corrosion resistance or improved aerodynamics.Size and Fitment
Choosing the correct wheel size and offset is vital to avoid rubbing or clearance issues. Larger wheels can enhance styling but may affect ride quality and efficiency if not matched properly. Always verify the diameter, width, and offset specifications for your Tesla Model S model year to ensure seamless fitment and safety. Using wheels that are too small or large can impact braking performance and suspension geometry, so consult your vehicle’s manual or a professional before making a selection.
Material and Construction
Materials like aluminum alloys provide a good balance of strength and weight savings, which benefits handling and efficiency. Heavier steel wheels are more durable but can negatively impact range and acceleration. Look for wheels with quality finishes (e.g., powder coating or anodizing) to resist corrosion, especially if you frequently drive in harsh climates. Poorly made wheels may crack or corrode over time, so investing in reputable brands can save money in the long run.
Design and Aerodynamics
The wheel design influences more than just aesthetics; it affects airflow and noise. Aero wheels with enclosed surfaces can improve efficiency by reducing drag, which benefits range. Conversely, intricate spoke designs may look more aggressive but could increase turbulence and noise. Consider your driving environment and preferences when selecting a style that aligns with your priorities—whether sleek looks or efficiency gains.
Cost and Value
Price points vary widely, from budget-friendly OEM reconditioned options to high-end custom alloys. Cheaper wheels might save money upfront but could lack durability or proper fitment, leading to potential safety concerns. Premium wheels typically offer benefits like better heat dissipation, corrosion resistance, and weight savings, which can justify the higher cost for dedicated Tesla owners or enthusiasts. Balance your budget with your expectations for longevity and performance.
Additional Features to Consider
Features such as corrosion resistance, ease of cleaning, and compatibility with tire pressure monitoring systems (TPMS) matter depending on your local climate and maintenance preferences. Some wheels include integrated cooling channels to improve brake performance, especially on spirited driving or frequent hill climbs. Also, check if the wheels are compatible with your existing tires or if new tires are recommended, factoring in overall cost and installation effort.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install 19-inch wheels on my Tesla Model S that originally has 21-inch wheels?
Installing 19-inch wheels on a Model S designed for 21-inch wheels is possible but requires careful consideration of compatibility. The smaller diameter could alter handling characteristics and affect speedometer accuracy. You may also need a different tire size to maintain the correct overall diameter, which can impact ride comfort and efficiency. Consulting with a Tesla specialist or professional installer before making such changes helps ensure safety and performance are preserved.
Are aftermarket wheels safe for long-term use on my Tesla Model S?
Yes, aftermarket wheels can be safe if they are high-quality, properly rated for your vehicle, and correctly installed. Look for wheels made from reputable brands with certifications such as ISO or SAE standards. Proper maintenance, including regular checks for cracks or corrosion, also extends their lifespan. Avoid cheap, uncertified options, as these can compromise safety and durability over time.
Will changing to aftermarket wheels affect my Tesla’s warranty?
Changing wheels can potentially impact your vehicle’s warranty if the modifications cause damage or interfere with systems like the brakes or sensors. Tesla’s warranty typically covers original parts, so installing non-OEM wheels may void certain aspects if issues arise directly related to the upgrade. It’s advisable to consult Tesla or a certified installer beforehand and keep detailed records of your purchase and installation process.
How do I choose the best wheels for improving range on my Tesla Model S?
To maximize range, opt for wheels with aerodynamic designs and lightweight materials like alloys. Enclosed or aero-style wheels reduce drag, helping your Tesla conserve energy during highway driving. Avoid heavy or non-aerodynamic designs that add rolling resistance. Remember, larger wheels or aggressive styling might look appealing but can negatively impact efficiency, so balance aesthetics with your goal of extending range.
What maintenance is required for aftermarket wheels on a Tesla Model S?
Maintaining aftermarket wheels involves regular cleaning to remove brake dust and road grime, which can cause corrosion if left unchecked. Periodic inspections for cracks, bends, or corrosion are recommended, especially if you frequently drive on rough roads. Applying protective coatings can help preserve the finish and prevent corrosion, particularly in salty or humid environments. Proper torqueing of lug nuts during installation also ensures safety and prevents damage.
Conclusion
For those seeking the best overall upgrade, the 21-inch Replacement Wheel Set offers a balanced mix of style, durability, and value. Budget-conscious buyers will appreciate the 19″ OEM Reconditioned Wheels for affordability, while enthusiasts focused on premium quality should consider the Tesla Model S/X Volume Scroll Infinity Wheels (Black) for their sleek design and premium materials. Novice owners or casual drivers may prefer simpler, OEM-replacement options, whereas performance-oriented drivers should prioritize lightweight, aerodynamically optimized wheels. Ultimately, your choice depends on whether you prioritize cost, style, or performance—each category has a standout option to match your needs.Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
