For most drivers, I’d start with the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3: it appears in several sizes here, making it the most adaptable performance-focused choice in this lineup. The Scorpion All Season Plus 3 is a stronger fit for SUV and crossover owners seeking a touring-oriented option, while the Cinturato P7 All Season Run Flat suits drivers whose vehicle calls for run-flat capability. The main tradeoffs are performance feel versus touring comfort, vehicle-specific fit, and whether you need run-flat construction. Tire size and your vehicle’s requirements can narrow the field before brand or model preference does. Continue reading for the full breakdown and guidance on choosing among these 15 Pirelli tires.
Get garage and car supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
The P Zero All Season Plus 3 leads this lineup for versatility, with four listed sizes spanning different wheel diameters and performance-oriented fitments.
Several listings are the same model in different sizes; compare the exact size and load and speed ratings rather than treating each listing as a different tire design.
The Scorpion options serve distinct SUV needs: the All Season Plus 3 is the touring-oriented choice, while the Scorpion Zero All Season and Scorpion STR provide alternative fitments and model lines.
Run-flat capability is a specific requirement, not a universal upgrade. The two Cinturato P7 listings are the options here identified as run-flat, so vehicle compatibility should lead the decision.
The P Zero All Season and P Zero All Season Plus 3 are not interchangeable just because their names are similar. Check the exact product designation, size, and vehicle fit before choosing between them.
| Pirelli tire | Tire size | Load index | Maximum pressure | Tread depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | 245/40R18 | 97 | 50 psi | 10/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | 245/45R20 | 103 | 50 psi | 10/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/ | 215/55R17 | 94 | 51 psi | 9/32 inches |
| Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Seas | 255/55R20 | 107 | 44 psi | — |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Seaso | 205/55R17 | 91 | 44 psi | — |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | 225/65R17 | 102 | 44 psi | 12/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | 245/60R18 | 105 | 51 psi | 10/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/ | 235/45R18 | 94 | 51 psi | 9/32 inches |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Seaso | 245/40R18 | 97 | 50 psi | 10/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | 245/45R19 | 102 | 50 psi | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Perf | 215/55R17 94V | 94 | 51 psi | 9/32 inches |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | 255/35R19 96Y | — | 50 psi | 10/32 inch |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | 245/40R19 98Y | 98 | — | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/ | 235/45R18 94V | 94 | 51 psi | 10/32 inches |
| Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 | 245/50R20 102H | 102 | 44 psi | 12/32 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 245/40R18 97Y XL Passenger Tire
The P Zero All Season Plus 3 is my strongest fit here for drivers who want a performance-oriented tire in a common 18-inch size without giving up a stated 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty. Its asymmetrical tread and dense siping are intended to support handling and braking while tempering road noise; four wide grooves help move water and slush away from the contact area. Compared with the 215/55R17 P Zero All Season, this Plus 3 version has a newer model designation and a longer listed warranty, but it is an XL-rated fitment intended for compatible vehicles, not a universal upgrade. One listing inconsistency deserves attention: despite the all-season name, its season field says Summer. I would verify the tire’s approved use and your vehicle fitment before buying, especially if winter conditions are part of the plan.
Pros:- Asymmetrical tread and dense siping are designed to support handling, braking, and grip.
- Four wide grooves help channel water and slush.
- Siping is intended to reduce road noise and vibration.
- Includes a 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread-life warranty.
Cons:- The listed season says Summer despite the All Season product name, so intended seasonal use is unclear.
- XL load range and 245/40R18 size may not match many vehicles.
- The listing does not establish that it suits every vehicle described as a coupe or sedan.
Best for: Drivers of compatible performance-oriented coupes and sedans needing a 245/40R18 tire with an all-season product designation and a listed tread-life warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need a clearly winter-rated tire or owners whose vehicle does not call for this size and XL load range; the supplied listing has conflicting season information.
- Tire size:245/40R18
- Load index:97
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Tire diameter:25.71 inches
- Tread-life warranty:50,000-mile limited manufacturer warranty
Our verdict“Choose this Plus 3 for a compatible 18-inch performance sedan when its fitment and seasonal specification check out.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 245/45R20 103Y XL Passenger Tire
This 20-inch P Zero All Season Plus 3 suits buyers whose vehicle specifically calls for a 245/45R20 tire and who want the same performance-focused tread approach as the 18-inch Plus 3 pick. Its asymmetrical pattern, dense siping, and wide grooves are designed to balance handling with wet-road water evacuation, while the 50,000-mile limited warranty gives it a stated longevity benchmark. Against the 245/40R18 Plus 3, this version has a higher load index and a larger wheel fitment, but those differences do not make it a substitute: the correct size and load requirements come from the vehicle, not a preference for a larger rim. The listing also labels the season Summer even though the product name says All Season. That ambiguity, plus its performance-car focus, makes careful fitment and seasonal verification part of the purchase decision.
Pros:- 20-inch fitment for vehicles designed around this size.
- Asymmetrical tread and siping are designed to support handling and braking.
- Wide grooves help channel water and reduce hydroplaning risk.
- Carries a 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread-life warranty.
Cons:- The listed Summer season conflicts with the All Season product name.
- Performance-coupe and sedan focus limits its suitability for other vehicle types.
- Its 20-inch size is not interchangeable with the 18-inch Plus 3 without vehicle approval.
Best for: Owners of compatible performance-oriented sedans or coupes that specify 245/45R20 and need an XL tire with a listed tread-life warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose vehicles require a different size or load rating, or buyers who need an unambiguous winter-use specification.
- Tire size:245/45R20
- Rim size:20 inches
- Load index:103
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Tread-life warranty:50,000-mile limited manufacturer warranty
Our verdict“Pick this version only when 245/45R20 is the approved fitment and you have confirmed the tire’s intended seasonal use.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/55R17 94V Tire
For a vehicle specified for 215/55R17, this P Zero All Season is the more restrained-size option in a lineup otherwise weighted toward larger wheels and performance fitments. Pirelli describes it for luxury sedans and sports cars, with an asymmetrical tread and specialized rubber compounds aimed at grip, handling, and comfort across varied conditions. Compared with the newer-named P Zero All Season Plus 3 options, this tire’s supplied data does not list a tread-life warranty, so buyers have less stated longevity information to weigh. Its vehicle-specific fit designation also makes it a poor candidate for casual substitution. The provided specs list year-round seasons, but they do not establish dedicated severe-winter capability. I’d favor it for everyday use where the exact size and a comfort-oriented performance balance matter more than XL load capacity or a listed warranty.
Pros:- Year-round use is specified in the product data.
- Asymmetrical tread is designed to support handling and grip.
- Developed for a balance of driving comfort and performance.
- Vehicle-specific fit designation helps flag the need to match approved fitment.
Cons:- No tread-life warranty is provided in the supplied product data.
- Vehicle-specific fit limits its use as a replacement for other sizes.
- The listed specs do not establish dedicated severe-winter performance.
Best for: Drivers of luxury sedans or sports cars that specify 215/55R17 and want an asymmetrical tire described for year-round driving.
Not ideal for: Owners needing a different fitment, a higher load capacity, or a clearly stated tread-life warranty; winter-focused drivers should confirm suitability for local conditions.
- Tire size:215/55R17
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Season:Year round
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Fit type:Vehicle-specific
Our verdict“Choose this P Zero when your vehicle calls for 215/55R17 and you prefer a year-round performance tire over an XL Plus 3 fitment.”
Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season 255/55R20 107H SUV/Crossover Tire
Unlike the P Zero options aimed at cars, the Scorpion Zero All Season is built around SUV, crossover, and light-truck use. Its four longitudinal grooves are designed to clear water, while optimized siping and curved tread blocks target control in wet and snowy conditions. Pirelli’s Noise Cancelling System gives this pick a comfort advantage on the road that the supplied P Zero descriptions do not claim. It also lists a 2,150-pound load capacity, making it relevant to heavier vehicles when the tire’s size and ratings match the door placard. The tradeoff is a listed weight of 40.1 pounds, considerably more than the passenger-tire options here, and the directional tread may affect rotation choices. I’d choose it for a properly matched SUV, not as a general-purpose upgrade for a sedan.
Pros:- Four wide longitudinal grooves are designed to improve wet-road water evacuation.
- Pirelli Noise Cancelling System is intended to reduce cabin noise.
- Optimized siping and curved blocks target grip in wet and snowy conditions.
- Listed load capacity is 2,150 pounds per tire.
Cons:- At 40.1 pounds, it is heavier than the passenger-tire choices in this group.
- Directional tread can limit tire-rotation options compared with asymmetrical designs.
- The SUV-oriented size and ratings make it unsuitable for many passenger cars.
Best for: SUV and crossover owners whose approved fitment is 255/55R20 and who prioritize wet-road control, cabin quiet, and suitable load capacity.
Not ideal for: Passenger-car drivers or SUV owners whose required size, load index, or rotation needs do not match this directional tire.
- Tire size:255/55R20
- Load index:107
- Load capacity:2,150 pounds
- Season:All season
- Tread type:Directional
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Construction:Radial
- Weight:40.1 pounds
Our verdict“Select the Scorpion Zero for a compatible SUV or crossover when quiet running and wet-weather control matter more than lighter construction.”
Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Run Flat Radial Tire – 205/55R17 91H
The Cinturato P7 All Season Run Flat fills a different need from the performance-led P Zero tires: it pairs an everyday touring purpose with run-flat construction. That capability can let a driver continue a limited journey after a puncture, subject to the vehicle maker’s instructions, rather than stopping immediately to fit a spare. Its asymmetrical tread and all-season designation suit routine year-round driving, while the listed 500AA UTQG provides a wear-rating reference absent from the supplied specs for the P Zero All Season 215/55R17. The compromise is ride comfort: run-flat construction can feel firmer than a conventional tire, and this exact 205/55R17 size fits only vehicles approved for it. I’d put it ahead of the P Zero choices for puncture mobility, not for drivers chasing the sportiest feel or the broadest fitment flexibility.
Pros:- Run-flat construction can provide limited mobility after a puncture when used as directed.
- All-season designation suits routine driving across seasons.
- Asymmetrical tread design supports everyday traction.
- 500AA UTQG offers a stated treadwear and traction rating reference.
Cons:- Run-flat construction can produce a firmer ride than a standard tire.
- The specific 205/55R17 fitment restricts compatibility.
- Run-flat use must match vehicle requirements and operating instructions.
Best for: Drivers with a vehicle approved for 205/55R17 run-flat tires who want all-season use and added mobility after a puncture.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose vehicle is not equipped or approved for run-flat tires, or those who place a soft ride above puncture mobility.
- Tire size:205/55R17
- Load index:91
- Season:All season
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Load capacity:1,356 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- UTQG:500AA
- Construction:Radial run-flat
Our verdict“Choose this Cinturato P7 when your vehicle is run-flat compatible and puncture mobility matters more than ride softness.”
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 Touring All-Season Tire, 225/65R17 102H
The Scorpion All Season Plus 3 is the lineup’s clearest fit for crossover and SUV drivers who want one tire for routine year-round use. Its full-depth 3D sipes are intended to maintain grip as the tread wears, while the asymmetric pattern is designed for wet, dry, and snowy-road traction. Pirelli also positions it for a quieter, more comfortable ride, a useful priority in a family vehicle. Compared with the more performance-focused P Zero All Season Plus 3, this Scorpion puts vehicle type and touring comfort ahead of sporty response. The tradeoff is that its all-season design is not a substitute for a dedicated winter tire in severe snow or cold. The supplied product details also do not specify a particular performance test or winter certification, so buyers should match it to their vehicle and local conditions.
Pros:- Designed specifically for crossovers, SUVs, and pickup trucks
- Asymmetric tread and full-depth 3D sipes are intended to support traction in wet, dry, and snowy conditions
- Touring-focused design aims for a quieter, more comfortable ride
- Listed 70,000-mile warranty
Cons:- All-season capability does not make it a dedicated severe-winter tire
- Less performance-oriented than the P Zero All Season Plus 3
- Product details provide limited evidence for comparing its performance with other tires
Best for: Crossover, SUV, and pickup owners seeking a touring-oriented tire for everyday driving across varied seasons.
Not ideal for: Drivers who regularly face severe winter weather or want a performance tire tuned for sharper sporty handling.
- Tire size:225/65R17
- Load index:102
- Load capacity:1,874 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Tire diameter:28.5 inches
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Listed warranty:70,000 miles
Our verdict“Choose this Scorpion for touring comfort and all-season versatility in a crossover or SUV, not for severe winter driving or sporty handling.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire, 245/60R18 (105Y)
This P Zero All Season is the choice here for drivers who want responsive steering in a taller 18-inch fitment without stepping up to the newer P Zero All Season Plus 3. Its asymmetric tread assigns different jobs to different zones: outer-block siping is intended to aid cornering and water control, while inner-block siping targets snow traction. That makes it a more handling-minded alternative to the comfort-oriented Scorpion All Season Plus 3. There is a meaningful data caveat, though: the listing describes it as all-season but also labels the season field “Summer,” and its speed designation conflicts between 105Y in the title and 105H in a highlight. I would verify the exact sidewall specification and vehicle fitment before buying. Its 10/32-inch tread depth is also shallower than the Scorpion’s listed 12/32 inches.
Pros:- Asymmetric tread uses distinct siping zones for cornering and snow traction
- Design aims to balance responsive steering with a quieter ride
- Listed load capacity is 2,039 pounds per tire
- 18-inch size and 29.57-inch diameter are clearly specified
Cons:- Listing conflicts on season classification, with both all-season and summer labels
- Speed designation conflicts between 105Y and 105H in the supplied details
- Listed 10/32-inch tread depth is less than the Scorpion All Season Plus 3’s 12/32 inches
Best for: Drivers with a compatible 18-inch fitment who prioritize steering response and want an all-season tread design for varied everyday conditions.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need unambiguous speed and season specifications, or who want a touring-first tire with the Scorpion’s deeper listed tread.
- Tire size:245/60R18
- Load index:105
- Speed designation:Title lists Y; product highlight lists H
- Load capacity:2,039 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Tire diameter:29.57 inches
- Rim size:18 inches
Our verdict“Consider this P Zero for steering-focused all-season use only after confirming its exact speed rating and season designation.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/45R18 94V Tire
For a luxury sedan or sports car in the specified size, this P Zero All Season aims to combine year-round usability with a handling-oriented feel. Its asymmetric tread and specialized compounds are designed to support grip across changing conditions, while the product description also targets a smooth ride and long tread life. Compared with the 245/60R18 P Zero All Season, this 235/45R18 version suits a lower-profile fitment and has a lower listed load capacity, so the two are not interchangeable choices; vehicle fitment comes first. It is less clearly documented than the P Zero All Season Plus 3, whose listing specifies a 50,000-mile warranty. Here, no warranty figure or specific winter rating is supplied, and results may vary with weather and driving conditions.
Pros:- Year-round design for varied weather conditions
- Asymmetric tread and specialized compounds are intended to support handling and grip
- Designed to balance smooth comfort with tread life
- Specifications include an 18-inch rim and 8-inch rim width
Cons:- No tread-life warranty figure is provided in the product data
- Performance can vary with weather and driving conditions
- Listed load capacity is lower than that of the 245/60R18 P Zero All Season
Best for: Luxury-sedan and sports-car owners whose vehicle calls for 235/45R18 tires and who want an all-season, handling-focused option.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking a documented tread-life warranty, severe-snow capability, or a tire for a different required size or load rating.
- Tire size:235/45R18
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Tire diameter:26.34 inches
- Rim width:8 inches
- Season:Year-round
Our verdict“This is a fitment-specific pick for sedan and sports-car drivers who want P Zero handling character but do not need a stated mileage warranty.”
Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Run Flat Touring Tire, 245/40R18 97H
The Cinturato P7 All Season Run Flat is the lineup’s touring choice for drivers whose vehicle is designed for run-flat tires and who value the added mobility associated with that format. Its wide grooves are intended to channel water away, while the tread design targets steering response and reduced road noise. Compared with the sportier P Zero All Season Plus 3, it emphasizes touring traits and fuel-efficiency aims rather than an ultra-high-performance brief. Its winter promise is limited: the listing describes suitability for light winter conditions, not severe snow or extreme cold. The supplied specs also show an anomalous load-capacity value of “16 ounces,” so I would verify the correct tire specification with the seller or vehicle documentation. Seal Inside technology is only available on some sizes, and the listing does not confirm it for this one.
Pros:- Run-flat touring format for vehicles designed to use it
- Wide grooves are intended to move water away and reduce hydroplaning risk
- Tread design targets steering response and lower road noise
- All-season design includes light-winter use
Cons:- Not intended for severe winter conditions
- Seal Inside technology is listed as available only on some sizes, with no confirmation for this one
- Provided load capacity of 16 ounces appears inconsistent and should be verified
Best for: Sedan, coupe, or compatible CUV drivers whose vehicle requires a run-flat touring tire for year-round driving in mild winter conditions.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need severe-winter traction, confirmed Seal Inside technology on this size, or clear load-capacity information before purchase.
- Tire size:245/40R18
- Load index:97
- Speed designation:H
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Tire diameter:25.7 inches
- Load range:XL
- Season:Year-round
Our verdict“Choose this Cinturato when your vehicle calls for a run-flat touring tire and your winter driving is mild, after confirming its load specification.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 245/45R19 102Y XL Passenger Tire
The P Zero All Season Plus 3 earns the performance-focused spot in this group: its asymmetric tread, dense siping, and four wide grooves are designed to pair year-round grip with responsive handling and water evacuation. Compared with the touring-oriented Scorpion All Season Plus 3, this tire is aimed at coupes and sedans where handling matters more than SUV-focused comfort. Its listed 50,000-mile limited warranty gives buyers a defined tread-life term, unlike the 235/45R18 P Zero All Season listing, which supplies no warranty figure. The tradeoff is familiar for an all-season performance tire: it is not built for deep snow or extreme cold, and the product data gives a load capacity of “16 ounces,” which appears inconsistent. Confirm the correct load specification and vehicle fitment before purchase.
Pros:- Ultra-high-performance all-season design for coupes and sedans
- Dense siping and asymmetric tread are intended to support grip and handling
- Four wide grooves are designed to channel water and reduce hydroplaning risk
- Listed 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty
Cons:- Not a dedicated winter tire for deep snow or extreme cold
- Supplied load capacity of 16 ounces appears inconsistent and requires verification
- Performance-focused positioning may be less suited to buyers prioritizing SUV touring comfort
Best for: Coupe and sedan drivers with a compatible 245/45R19 fitment who want an all-season tire with a performance-oriented design and stated tread-life coverage.
Not ideal for: Drivers facing deep snow or extreme cold, or buyers who cannot verify the tire’s load capacity and vehicle fitment.
- Tire size:245/45R19
- Load index:102
- Speed designation:Y
- Load range:XL
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Overall diameter:27.68 inches
- Construction:Radial
- Listed warranty:50,000-mile limited warranty
Our verdict“Pick this P Zero for a compatible sedan or coupe when handling and a stated tread-life warranty matter more than severe-winter capability.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Performance Tire, 215/55R17 94V
This 215/55R17 P Zero All Season is a sensible match for drivers who want responsive steering without giving up all-season wet and light-snow capability. Its symmetrical tread channels water through the grooves, while inner-block siping is designed to add grip when roads turn wintry. The tread pattern also aims to limit cabin noise, a useful counterpoint to the firmer feel associated with performance tires. Compared with the newer P Zero All Season Plus 3 options in this roundup, this version offers a simpler fit for 17-inch wheels, but lacks their stated 50,000-mile tread-life warranty. It also does not promise the same added technology across every size: run-flat, PNCS, and SealInside features are available only on select fitments. Choose it for balanced everyday performance, not deep-snow driving or a guaranteed quieting feature package.
Pros:- Tread grooves are designed to evacuate water on wet roads
- Inner-block siping supports traction in light snow
- Tread pattern is engineered to reduce cabin noise
- 17-inch sizing suits many compact and midsize sedans
Cons:- No tread-life warranty is specified in the supplied product details
- RunFlat, PNCS, and SealInside features are limited to select sizes
- All-season performance is not a substitute for a dedicated winter tire in severe snow
Best for: Drivers of sedans with 17-inch wheels who want steering response and wet-road confidence with some light-snow capability.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need dependable traction in deep or frequent snow, or who specifically require run-flat, PNCS, or SealInside features in this size.
- Tire size:215/55R17 94V
- Rim size:17 inches
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Season:All season
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
Our verdict“Choose this P Zero if your 17-inch sedan needs responsive everyday handling and wet-road control, but skip it if a stated mileage warranty or severe-winter grip is a priority.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 255/35R19 96Y XL Passenger Tire
For a performance coupe or sedan on 19-inch wheels, this P Zero All Season Plus 3 pairs an asymmetrical tread with dense siping to support handling, braking, and grip across changing conditions. Four wide grooves are intended to move water and slush away from the contact area, addressing a key all-season concern at this low-profile size. The listed 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty gives it a clearer ownership benchmark than the 215/55R17 P Zero All Season, whose supplied details do not state a mileage warranty. Against the 245/40R19 Plus 3 in this group, this 255/35R19 version is wider and has a lower aspect ratio, so fitment and ride priorities matter. One data point needs checking before purchase: the listing calls the tire ultra-high-performance all-season but also gives a summer season specification.
Pros:- Asymmetrical tread is designed to support handling and braking
- Four wide grooves help channel water and slush
- Dense siping is intended to reduce road noise and vibration
- Includes a 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty
Cons:- Listing gives conflicting seasonal information: all-season product description and summer season specification
- Low 35-series sidewall may suit handling priorities better than ride comfort
- XL load range and exact vehicle fitment should be checked before buying
Best for: Coupe and sedan owners whose vehicle calls for 255/35R19 XL tires and who want performance-oriented handling with an included tread-life warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking a conventional high-sidewall ride, or anyone who needs an unambiguous seasonal specification before selecting a tire.
- Tire size:255/35R19 96Y
- Rim size:19 inches
- Load range:XL
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Construction:Radial
- Tread depth:10/32 inch
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Warranty:50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty
Our verdict“Pick this Plus 3 for a correctly specified 255/35R19 performance car when its warranty and wet-weather tread design fit your needs, after confirming the season designation.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 Tire 245/40R19 98Y XL
The 245/40R19 P Zero All Season Plus 3 suits drivers who want a performance-focused tire with design features aimed at making year-round road use less demanding. Its four wide grooves help channel water and slush, while dense siping is intended to support grip and keep road noise in check. That makes it a more rounded choice than the older 235/45R18 P Zero All Season, which uses a symmetrical tread and has no warranty listed in its supplied details. It shares the Plus 3 family’s stated 50,000-mile limited warranty with the 255/35R19 option, but this 245/40R19 size has a taller aspect ratio and a slightly different fitment profile. The listing provides fewer technical details than its sibling, and the XL 19-inch fit still calls for a vehicle-specific fit check. It is not a dedicated winter tire, despite its year-round positioning.
Pros:- Asymmetrical tread is designed for year-round handling and traction
- Four wide grooves support water and slush evacuation
- Dense siping is intended to reduce road noise and vibration
- Includes a 50,000-mile limited warranty
Cons:- Not a replacement for a dedicated winter tire in severe snow
- Supplied specifications omit details such as maximum pressure and tread depth
- XL 19-inch fitment must match the vehicle’s approved tire size
Best for: Drivers of coupes or sedans that specify 245/40R19 XL tires and want a performance-oriented all-season option with a stated tread-life warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers in areas with frequent severe snow, or buyers who need a complete set of published specifications before choosing a fitment.
- Tire size:245/40R19 98Y
- Rim size:19 inches
- Load index:98
- Load range:XL
- Construction:Radial
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Weight:23.5 pounds
- Warranty:50,000-mile limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose this Plus 3 when your vehicle calls for 245/40R19 XL and you want a warranty-backed performance all-season tire rather than the older, symmetrical P Zero All Season.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/45R18 94V Tire
This 235/45R18 P Zero All Season is the straightforward choice for drivers whose sedan calls for this 18-inch size and who want steering response across changing weather. Its ribbed symmetrical tread is designed to feel responsive, while circumferential grooves help clear water and the siping supports wet-road control and some snow traction. Compared with the 215/55R17 version in this roundup, it has a larger rim fitment and a deeper listed tread depth, but both share the same basic P Zero All Season approach rather than the newer Plus 3’s asymmetrical tread and stated 50,000-mile warranty. Pirelli also cites nanofiller and silane compounds to support stiffness and consistent performance. The tradeoff is that the supplied details do not include a mileage warranty, and noise-cancelling, run-flat, and SealInside features are not guaranteed for this size.
Pros:- Ribbed tread design supports steering response
- Circumferential grooves help clear water
- Siping is designed to support wet-road and light-snow traction
- 10/32-inch tread depth is specified
Cons:- No mileage warranty is stated in the supplied product data
- Run-flat, noise-cancelling, and SealInside features are available only on select sizes
- All-season snow capability does not equal dedicated winter performance
Best for: Sedan owners with an approved 235/45R18 fitment who want responsive steering, wet-road water evacuation, and some light-snow capability.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need a stated tread-life warranty, guaranteed run-flat or noise-cancelling features, or strong performance in severe winter conditions.
- Tire size:235/45R18 94V
- Rim size:18 inches
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Tire diameter:26.34 inches
Our verdict“Choose this 18-inch P Zero for everyday steering response and wet-road control when the size matches your sedan, but favor a Plus 3 if a stated tread-life warranty matters more.”
Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 102H SUV/Crossover Tire
Unlike the P Zero passenger-car options in this roundup, the Scorpion STR is shaped for SUV and crossover fitments, with a 20-inch wheel size and a higher stated load capacity. Its traction grooves and X-Sipe technology are designed to support wet, snowy, and icy-road performance, while Sport Plus Technology targets handling and braking. A 50,000-mile limited mileage warranty is included, giving buyers a stated tread-life reference not provided for the older P Zero All Season models. The tradeoff is that this is a much larger, heavier fitment than the 17-, 18-, and 19-inch passenger tires here, so it only makes sense when the vehicle’s specifications call for 245/50R20. Its all-season design should not be treated as a substitute for winter tires in harsh conditions. The listing also says it is not for sale in Arkansas.
Pros:- SUV/crossover-oriented 245/50R20 fitment
- Traction grooves and X-Sipe technology target wet and wintry-road grip
- Sport Plus Technology supports handling and braking
- Includes a 50,000-mile limited mileage warranty
Cons:- Only appropriate for vehicles approved for this 20-inch size
- All-season tread is not a dedicated solution for severe winter conditions
- Listed as not for sale in Arkansas
Best for: SUV and crossover owners whose vehicle specifies 245/50R20 tires and who want an all-season option with a stated mileage warranty.
Not ideal for: Passenger-car owners, drivers needing a dedicated severe-winter tire, and buyers located in Arkansas where this product is listed as unavailable for sale.
- Tire size:245/50R20 102H
- Vehicle type:SUV/crossover
- Rim size:20 inches
- Load index:102
- Load capacity:1,874 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Warranty:50,000-mile limited mileage warranty
Our verdict“Choose the Scorpion STR if your SUV or crossover requires 245/50R20 and you want all-season traction plus a stated mileage warranty; skip it for passenger cars or severe-winter use.”
How We Picked
I organized the ranking around the needs suggested by the product names, vehicle categories, and listed specifications: performance-oriented passenger-car use, touring-oriented SUV use, and run-flat fitments. I gave the broadest recommendation to a model represented in several sizes, then placed more specialized options according to who they suit. The listed tire size, load index, speed rating, and vehicle type matter because a tire must match the vehicle’s requirements before its model name can guide a purchase.
This is a comparison of the supplied product listings, not a claim of independent road testing. The listings do not provide comparable test data for wet braking, snow traction, tread life, noise, or fuel economy, so I do not rank tires on unsupported performance claims. Where products repeat the same model in different sizes, I treat the size as a fitment distinction rather than evidence of a different design. A tire that does not match the vehicle placard or manufacturer guidance should rank below a compatible alternative, even if its model appears higher in this guide.
| Pirelli tire | Tread type |
|---|---|
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/ | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Seas | Directional |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Seaso | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/ | — |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Seaso | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Perf | Symmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 235/ | Symmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Pirelli Tires
Before choosing a model, I’d narrow the decision by vehicle fit and the job the tire needs to do. These listings mix passenger-car P Zero options, SUV and crossover Scorpions, and Cinturato P7 run-flats. Those categories are not direct substitutes, so the right comparison starts with your vehicle’s approved specifications and your priorities for everyday driving.
Start With the Vehicle Placard, Not the Model Name
Read the tire information placard on the driver’s door area and your owner’s manual before comparing models. Match the complete size, including width, aspect ratio, and wheel diameter, along with the required load index and speed rating. A similar-looking size may not have the correct clearance or capacity for your vehicle. Do not assume that a larger wheel size is an upgrade your car can accept. If the listing omits a specification you need, verify it with the tire seller or manufacturer instead of inferring compatibility from the model family. This step can eliminate most unsuitable choices before you weigh driving preferences.
Choose Performance or Touring Priorities
Performance-oriented passenger tires and touring-oriented tires answer different daily-driving priorities. A performance-focused choice may suit drivers who want a more responsive character, while a touring model may be a better match for routine commuting and utility use. The product names help identify intended categories, but they do not establish comparative braking distances, ride comfort, or tread life. Avoid assuming that a sportier label means better results in every weather condition. Think about your usual roads, typical trip length, and whether sharper response matters more than a calmer everyday setup. Then seek independent testing for the exact tire and size if measured performance is a deciding factor.
Treat All-Season as a Category, Not a Snow Guarantee
“All season” does not mean every tire performs equally in cold weather, heavy rain, or snow. The listings here do not supply comparable winter test results, so I would not use the category name alone to choose a tire for frequent snow or ice. Check the tire’s sidewall markings and independent tests for the exact size if winter traction is part of the decision. Drivers in areas with severe winter conditions may need a dedicated winter tire rather than relying on a general all-season designation. Also think about whether you can store and change seasonal tires, since that affects the practical tradeoff. Match the tire to your local conditions, not just the broad label.
Buy Run-Flat Only When the Vehicle and Use Call for It
Run-flat construction can help a driver continue to a safe stopping place after a loss of air pressure, but it is not a blanket substitute for a spare or roadside plan. The Cinturato P7 listings are the only products in this group explicitly identified as run-flat. Confirm that your vehicle is approved for run-flat tires and check the manufacturer’s instructions for pressure monitoring and post-puncture driving limits. Some vehicles are designed around run-flat fitments, while others may require changes to suspension setup or equipment. Compare the convenience of limited mobility after a puncture against the ride and replacement considerations described in vehicle-specific guidance. If your car does not require run-flats, compare compatible conventional tires too.
Compare the Full Specification, Not Just the Wheel Diameter
Two tires with the same model name can differ in size, load index, speed rating, and construction. This roundup includes repeated model families across several fitments, so a matching product name does not make the listings interchangeable. XL markings indicate a different load specification from a standard-load version; choose only what your vehicle calls for. Check that the load and speed ratings meet or exceed the vehicle maker’s requirements, while keeping the original fitment guidance in view. Confirm the exact product code and sidewall details before ordering, especially when comparing similar sizes. This avoids selecting a tire that appears close but does not satisfy the vehicle’s requirements.
Use Independent Evidence for Tread Life and Weather Tradeoffs
The supplied listings do not include comparable data on tread life, wet braking, road noise, or fuel consumption. I would treat those as open questions rather than assuming one Pirelli family is best across all measures. Look for independent tests that use the same or a closely matching size and compare conditions similar to your driving. Warranty terms can help frame expected service, but they are not a promise of how long a tire will last in your use. Driving style, alignment, inflation, rotation, and road surface all affect wear. Paying more for a model makes more sense when verified performance or a required fitment justifies the difference for your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Pirelli tire in this roundup is the best starting point for a passenger car?
I’d begin with the P Zero All Season Plus 3 if your car’s approved fitment matches one of the listed sizes. It has the broadest presence in this group, with four size listings, so it offers more fitment choices than any other single model family here. That does not make every listed size suitable for every car, and the model name alone cannot confirm compatibility. Compare the placard’s size, load index, and speed rating against the exact listing. If the fit does not match, select a compatible P Zero or Cinturato option instead.
Are the P Zero All Season and P Zero All Season Plus 3 the same tire?
No; the listings identify them as separate model names, so I would not treat them as interchangeable. This roundup includes multiple P Zero All Season Plus 3 sizes as well as P Zero All Season listings and a P Zero All Season Performance listing. The names alone do not provide enough evidence to claim how their measured wet grip, comfort, or tread life compare. Check the exact tire name and specifications against your vehicle’s requirements. If model performance is the deciding factor, consult independent tests for the exact product and size.
Should I choose a run-flat Cinturato P7 if my car came with conventional tires?
Not without checking your vehicle maker’s guidance first. The Cinturato P7 options here are identified as run-flat, but that feature does not automatically make them a suitable replacement for conventional tires. The vehicle may have specific requirements for tire construction, pressure monitoring, suspension, and spare-tire arrangements. If your car was not designed or approved for run-flats, ask the manufacturer or a qualified tire professional about compatibility before buying. A conventional tire that matches the approved fitment may be the simpler choice.
Which Pirelli option should I compare first for an SUV or crossover?
I’d first compare the Scorpion All Season Plus 3 if you want the touring-oriented option represented in this lineup. The Scorpion Zero All Season and Scorpion STR are also listed for SUV or crossover fitments, but the supplied details do not establish a performance ranking among them. Match the exact size and load rating to your vehicle, then identify whether your priority is routine road use, a particular handling character, or another vehicle-specific requirement. Do not assume every Scorpion model fits every SUV. Independent testing in your size can help settle close comparisons.
Can I replace just two tires with a different Pirelli model?
That depends on your vehicle’s drivetrain, the existing tires, and the manufacturer’s instructions. Mixing tire models can create differences in grip and handling, while some all-wheel-drive systems have tight limits for tread-depth variation. Before replacing only two, confirm whether the new tires can be paired safely with the remaining tires and whether they must go on a specific axle. Keep size, construction, load rating, and speed rating compatible across the set. A tire professional can check tread depth and vehicle guidance before you decide whether to replace two or all four.
Conclusion
For the best overall starting point, I’d choose the P Zero All Season Plus 3 in the exact size approved for your car; its several listed fitments make it the most flexible model family in this roundup. For an SUV or crossover driver prioritizing a touring-oriented option, the Scorpion All Season Plus 3 is the clearest match. The listings do not provide enough comparable data to name a true best-value tire by cost or tread life, so I’d call the best value the compatible model that meets your needs without paying for a feature your vehicle does not require. For a premium performance-oriented fit, start by checking the P Zero All Season Plus 3 specifications, but verify independent test results before paying extra for assumed performance. For beginners, begin with the vehicle placard and compare only matching sizes and ratings; the exact-fit P Zero All Season Plus 3 is a straightforward first option when approved. For a specific run-flat need, investigate the Cinturato P7 Run Flat, while confirming vehicle compatibility. Your vehicle’s approved fitment should make the final call.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
